logo Sign In

That guy with no name

User Group
Members
Join date
28-Dec-2020
Last activity
20-Aug-2025
Posts
1,041
Web Site
https://www.youtube.com/@TGWNN.

Post History

Post
#1660017
Topic
STAR WARS: EP VI -RETURN OF THE JEDI &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - ** PRODUCTION HAS NOW RESTARTED **
Time

ThiscouldbeR2D2 said:

Matt.F said:

exitzero said:

Any deleted scenes you want to use for fan edit but the quality was lacking, may not be off the table-

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlqN4h40dt8

I really hope that the deleted scene with Vader telepathically reaching out to Luke in the cave at the start of the film could be restored and reinserted into ROTJ:Revisited. It’s a scene that should never have been cut.

I think that scene recontextualises the whole movie for the better, it adds some depth and gravitas (which the film could do with to be honest), it rightfully places the Father/Son relationship front and centre, and makes the final act even more epic and impactful.

It’s certainly better condition footage than the deleted scene linked above with Luke using his binoculars, that one was far rougher. It would be quite a coup if the Vader and Luke scene could be sufficiently restored to add back in to Revisited, and for me it would be the single biggest improvement that could be made to ROTJ.

Sorry, but it’s not being included. In fact, Adywan retimed the shot with the wipe transition to R2 and 3PO so that there is no more of that slowdown that was added to make up for the removal of the scene.

He also said that scene was unusable due to its quality.

Post
#1659724
Topic
Does the 2K scan of Star wars from 1997 still exist?
Time

JadedSkywalker said:

They were meant for DVD. Why Lucas thought they were good enough for Blu-Ray, I really have no explanation. Not to mention further changes. And fixes.

Just to think even the 2020 UHD only happened because of the 3D release that was cancelled and those scans.

We had the same HD master on DVD, HDTV, and Blu-Ray for what 15 or 16 years.

John Lowry literally said that when the Blu-Rays would come out, Lucas would most likely come back for a better restoration… That never happened.

Post
#1659695
Topic
Does the 2K scan of Star wars from 1997 still exist?
Time

Anakin94 said:

YAREL_RGP said:
There is no 2K scan of the special edition trilogy, the restoration was all analog and physical,

And how the 2004 SE was made?
AFAIK it’s based on the 1997 SE 2k scan.

The 2004 scans were done in HD 1920x1080p 16-bit color. They were completed with only DVD mastering in mind, that’s why they are such bad quality.

Post
#1659407
Topic
⭐ Star Wars' <strong>50th anniversary</strong> in 2027 ⭐ | Your hopes and expectations <em>(if any)</em>...
Time

Broom Kid said:

Thanks for the extra context! And to add a little of my own - Fincher, Lee, and Cameron are, frankly, weirdos who seem to have gotten way too caught up in digital nonsense and AI adjustments, and have all caught a raft of shit for doing what they’re doing - especially when it comes to pretending like the movies they made 30 years ago were ACTUALLY made with modern equipment by the weird goateed men they are 30 years later. Lee’s basically not even a factor here anymore, and Cameron’s the only one still with any weight or power to force theaters to screen things in anything other than 2D 4K 24fps theatrically - and even in those instances it’s a tiny percentage of theaters that comply and those screenings aren’t going over well anyway.

I’d like for whoever posted that BS “8K/120fps” rumor to source where that rumor came from, honestly, so we can just straight up write that source off wholesale. I’d also suggest that, looking at what’s already been posted (the reddit thread, the YouTube Videos) we’re working with some pretty hard to argue with details, that are also being fed through some really squirrelly folks who are under the mistaken impression they have a lot of power they aren’t anywhere near holding, being super-nervous and scared about accidentally canceling a whole restoration that’s been ongoing for 3 years before the leak even happened and has now been formally announced a year and a half ahead of time, LOL.

You got the YouTuber not quite parsing what’s being given to him by folks who honestly think they can get a whole restoration shut down because they happened across a coding mistake that made this stuff visible on a private YouTube channel (which was happening whether they saw it or not, LOL) and people who are - honestly - ritualized and by force-of-habit, conditioned to disbelieve and poke holes in anything positive, to revert to figuring out how this is George Lucas’ fault and how he can still ruin it singlehandedly, and cite contract stipulations that don’t exist, to rationalize how none of this is actually coming to pass, despite the fact most of these details were already out there for a full month before an announcement even got made…

And now you ALSO apparently have folks who have no clue what’s going on, chiming in off to the side with “Rumors” based on misunderstanding how the restoration even works, seeing that the team is scanning some components of the OCN and the Interpositives (if not all of elements needed!) at 8K resolutions (if not higher) and presuming that means the restoration team (which, looking at the reddit descriptions of the leaks, isn’t even Lucasfilm OR Disney, but a third party working with them) is pulling a James Cameron on old trash 2K elements from decades ago because (???) and then just… saying it, and then other people just sharing it (with no accreditation) because (???)

Who the hell mentioned 120fps??? Also, films have been restored in 8K since the early 2000s, buddy. Don’t go barking up the wrong horse here… No one mentioned upscalling, or 120 FPS, not even ECK… All that just materialised here in this thread.

Post
#1659042
Topic
Star Wars: A New Hope DEVASTATOR EDITION (V.2 a WIP)
Time

Here’s the entire Throne room scene, I’ve decided to completely replace this sequence with the 19SE, as it has way more shadow and highlight details aswell as a hell of a lot more dynamic range:

2011 BD

DevEd V.2

2011 BD

DevEd V.2

It was still a pain to fix the frozen grain and match the color to the Adywan regrade, though…

Besides that, the changes are: Adjusted forest matte, Adjusted throne room matte, Artoo blinks red and blue, and the wipe has been completely redone, I wasn’t happy with both the theatrical and the SE freeze frame timing, the Theatrical just stops while chewie is still turning his head, and in the SE it stops while lea is moving her arms. So I’ve removed her arms from moving, and it looks much smoother. You can also see a sneak peek of the redone credits…

Gdrive: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QSSrZRujy6YlBoHvL8a75gbt2M6R1z3t/view?usp=sharing
Streamable: https://streamable.com/3qvzf0

Edit: Just realised I forgot to switch on the audio track during rendering… Oh, well…

Post
#1657566
Topic
Original trilogy: Special Edition 1997 restoration | TEMPORARILY UNAVAILABLE
Time

Mark’s Down On Your Syntax said:

I think there’s a bit too much cynicism in this thread. Give the Director a break, they’re clearly working very hard, on something, here.

Hey, we’ve all seen those first, second and third films in the trilogy at the quality level that they were in when we saw them, right? At some point in time, Director is going to make available their versions for download, and then we’ll all be able to watch the trilogy again in the quality level they are going to be in.

I’m hugely excited.

Looks like we’ve found TV’sFrink 2.0 🙄

Post
#1657134
Topic
<s>The inaccuracies in &quot;How Star Wars Was Saved in the Edit&quot;</s>
Time

lakamosque said:

RocketJump’s video is an advertising hit piece for a pretend film school. Blame George for the genuine screw ups he did, but heavily implying he was the cause for every problem in the movie, manipulating and lying, and going “Marcia! Marcia! Marcia!” is so utterly disingenuous. It just makes everyone that wants to see the theatrical versions look bad.

What lies? What manipulations? Please indulge me, you seem to be an expert.
“advertising hit piece”. Are you ok?

Post
#1656980
Topic
Star Wars: A New Hope DEVASTATOR EDITION (V.2 a WIP)
Time

G&G-Fan said:

I don’t really see it. And I think the positives outweigh the negatives.

What’s better, a butt ugly transfer that crushes a ton of detail and has weird colors, or a really good looking transfer that has some flaws when you really squint and look frame by frame?

Also… if you really wanted, you could just recolor the area around Luke.

It’s VERY noticeable:

It’s not possible to undo this because the masks have been feathered to oblivion and can’t be singled out and undone.

Post
#1656956
Topic
Star Wars: A New Hope DEVASTATOR EDITION (V.2 a WIP)
Time

This is very odd;

It’s not secret that the UHD Blu-rays use power windows (masks used to color adjust specific sections of a frame). I just wasn’t aware of the extent. Almost every other shot has them and they are absolutely horrible.

Take this shot, for example, they’ve brightened the outside of Luke’s garage with a simple feather mask, weird but ok. But then they have to mask Luke out independently so that he isn’t bright like the otusied, but they’ve done it so slopply the mask reveals the original color of the background behind him, not to mention the terrible matte lines:

2011 BD (cc by adywan)

UHD

UHD with highlighted masks

Red - inside garage
green - outside garage
B&W - Luke)

This shot has almost double the detail and color information as the BD clip, but because of these masks, it’s unusable. This is an example of why most professional resorations avoid using power windows or selective coloring, because it’s a destructive process that can’t be undone like with global grading.

Post
#1655183
Topic
Star Wars: A New Hope DEVASTATOR EDITION (V.2 a WIP)
Time

Concerning the 19SE remaster project:

Update:
This project has taken a bit of a backseat while I restart work on several other projects. It requires a hell of a lotta work, and I don’t want to rush it—so it’ll begin once DevEd 2.0 is done. When finished, it’ll likely be used to create DevEd 3.0, which will release much quicker since I’ve learned a lot since 1.0 and now use a non-destructive workflow, allowing me to swap out the source of effect shots with little to no adjustment. I’ve also become increasingly aware of the 2011 Blu-rays’ obsolete and honestly disgusting quality compared to the 19SE. 3.0 will be the final DevEd update, possibly before ANH:R HD, but who knows. As for 2.0, I expect it to be done soon, hopefully in a few months, definitely before the end of the year.

Post
#1655182
Topic
STAR WARS EPISODE IV - 2019 SE 4K blu-ray Remastered (WIP)
Time

Update:
This project has taken a bit of a backseat while I restart work on several other projects. It requires a hell of a lotta work, and I don’t want to rush it—so it’ll begin once DevEd 2.0 is done. When finished, it’ll likely be used to create DevEd 3.0, which will release much quicker since I’ve learned a lot since 1.0 and now use a non-destructive workflow, allowing me to swap out the source of effect shots with little to no adjustment. I’ve also become increasingly aware of the 2011 Blu-rays’ obsolete and honestly disgusting quality compared to the 19SE. 3.0 will be the final DevEd update, possibly before ANH:R HD, but who knows. As for 2.0, I expect it to be done soon, hopefully in a few months, definitely before the end of the year.

Post
#1654736
Topic
STAR WARS: EP VI -RETURN OF THE JEDI &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - ** PRODUCTION HAS NOW RESTARTED **
Time

oh_riginal said:

That guy with no name said:

oh_riginal said:

https://youtu.be/xPZigWFyK2o?si=T6kamsDQXcdtyT2G

In this clip, at around 5:36, there’s a moment from the Falcon’s cockpit view where it seems Lando has steered the ship to avoid hitting a wall, but the elements used for the ships in front of the Falcon move sideways along with the Falcon’s view in perfect unison, and this has always bothered me. It seems to just be a limitation of the effects at the time. I wonder, Adywan, do you see what I am talking about? And are there any plans to attempt a fix?

Also, does anyone even see what I’m talking about?

Screenshot?

I don’t think a screenshot would show what I’m seeing. You have to see it in motion.

If you’re talking about this shot:

I don’t see the problem you’re talking about, the ships are not moving “in perfect unison” they’re traveling at different speeds and from different angles…

Post
#1654728
Topic
STAR WARS: EP VI -RETURN OF THE JEDI &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - ** PRODUCTION HAS NOW RESTARTED **
Time

oh_riginal said:

https://youtu.be/xPZigWFyK2o?si=T6kamsDQXcdtyT2G

In this clip, at around 5:36, there’s a moment from the Falcon’s cockpit view where it seems Lando has steered the ship to avoid hitting a wall, but the elements used for the ships in front of the Falcon move sideways along with the Falcon’s view in perfect unison, and this has always bothered me. It seems to just be a limitation of the effects at the time. I wonder, Adywan, do you see what I am talking about? And are there any plans to attempt a fix?

Also, does anyone even see what I’m talking about?

Screenshot?

Post
#1654423
Topic
Star Wars: A New Hope DEVASTATOR EDITION (V.2 a WIP)
Time

G&G-Fan said:

That guy with no name said:

Either way, I absolutely hate these shots lol…

Why

Because there are some of the dirtiest on the print, I don’t hate the actual shots, I think they look great; that’s why I’m restoring them…

Here’s the finished shot; I haven’t used a single pixel of the Blu-ray or any other source, just 4K77, and 4K78 to remove dirt on the officer’s face where the dustbuster couldn’t work… When brightened up, the image had thousands of scratches and dirt, and other stuff which had to be removed manually… I also kept the original grain layer, unlike V1, where I DNR’ed it to smithereens, did a horrible patch job using still frames from the Blu-ray, etc, and then added a fake grain layer over everything…

Streamable: https://streamable.com/orbghv

There shouldn’t be a single dust particle left in it now:

Post
#1654025
Topic
STAR WARS: EP VI -RETURN OF THE JEDI &quot;REVISITED EDITION&quot;<strong>ADYWAN</strong> - ** PRODUCTION HAS NOW RESTARTED **
Time

Bingowings said:

Forgive me if this has been mentioned in the 157pages of this thread yet but in the current version Jerjerrod slows down and freezes (very artificially) to extend the scene for the transition to the droids approaching Jabba’s palace. It always bugged me as a kid. I don’t know if removing the saber construction scene meant they didn’t have enough frames accounted for but I hope it can be fixed. Either by using AI to add the missing frames or by doing some sort of edit to something else.

This has already been fixed, in the last video Adywan uploaded…